Pistachio Mint Pudding Pie Recipe

96 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 3 Pin It Share 14 StumbleUpon 79 Filament.io 96 Flares ×

This post is sponsored by Foodie.


Pistachio Mint Pudding Pie
To this day, a favorite treat of mine is pudding. It’s simple to make and satisfies my sweet tooth. With two fun holidays coming up in March, I thought it would totally be appropriate to come up with a pudding pie recipe. You might be wondering what two holidays I am referring to. Pi Day is March 14th and St. Patrick’s Day is the 17th. I put together a delectable collection on foodie that can help give you some inspiration on a simple dessert for after dinner, to take to a get together, or for pi day or St. Patricks Day.



It just makes sense to eat pie on Pi day and if you have some of this leftover green treat a few days later for St. Patrick’s Day, it’s a double win. You could also just make this pie again because it’s not one that lasts long, at least not at our home.


Pistachio Mint Pie Recipe


Pistachio pudding happens to be one of my favorite types of pudding. I combined it with another love of mine, andes mints, and found a match made in heaven. I present to you Pistachio Mint Pudding Pie.


5.0 from 10 reviews
Pistachio Mint Pudding Pie Recipe
Recipe type: Dessert
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 6
Pistachio Mint Pudding Pie
  • 1 3.5 oz box Pistachio Pudding
  • 1½ cups milk
  • 1½ cups cool whip
  • 15 Andes Mints, chopped
  • 1 Premade Chocolate Graham Crust
  • 1 cup Cool Whip
  1. In a large bowl, mix together pudding mix, milk, whipped topping and half of the Andes Mints.
  2. Pour into chocolate crust
  3. Freeze for 2 hours or until desired firmness is obtained
  4. Use remaining cool whip to top pie
  5. Sprinkle with remaining Andes Mints



Between myself, husband and two boys, this pie made it a whopping 2 hours in our house. It was THAT good. It took me about 10 minutes to put together and then was ready to eat after 2 hours in the freezer.


Pistachio Mint Pie


Are you a fan of pie?  What kind is your favorite?


This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, please see my Privacy Policy.


  1. 34
    Sandra VanHoey says:

    How I could go for a slice of that right now, that sounds wonderful

  2. 35
    Janet W. says:

    I absolutely love Andies mints! They are delicious! This pie looks amazing and I can’t wait to try your recipe!

  3. 36
    Maryann D. says:

    Pistachio is my favorite nut and they are good for you. This pie is pretty as well as sounding delicious, I would love it.

  4. 37
    Julie Wood says:

    I have to say that Pies are my favorite dessert, especially cream pies. This pie looks so delicious! I make my Banana Cream Pie over the weekend and it was so delicious. I like using real ingredients in my pies. I love the chocolate crust and the mints! YUM!

  5. 38
    Cheryl W. says:

    Oh my goodness, it has been forever and a day since I have had pistachio pudding. This pudding pie recipe looks devine and I must try it soon. Maybe this Sunday!

  6. 39

    Wow, this looks divine!

  7. 40

    Looks delicious! Thank you for the recipe!

  8. 41

    OOh this sounds great !I am a big mint fan too so I know I would love this…and the green makes a beautiful pie!
    trisha´s last blog post ..Buyers Guide to Diapers

  9. 42

    Pistachio and Mint – Yum! This looks really refreshing.
    robyn´s last blog post ..Plant a Truffula Tree with me!

  10. 43

    looks like some yummy fewds 😀

  11. 44

    That looks ridiculously good! The timing is definitely perfect for both holidays, too!

  12. 45

    This looks so delicious! This is perfect for st. patricks day!
    Melissa´s last blog post ..I love Waffle Love.

  13. 46

    Mmmmm this looks so good! I’m doing a similar version tomorrow but as a milkshake. I love pistachio.
    Cat Davis´s last blog post ..#CleanItForward with NEW Finish Power & Free #FinishMoms

  14. 48

    Chocolate ambrosia has always been a favorite but this looks positively delicious! I love mint!
    Nicole Brady´s last blog post ..The Best Birthday Gift for Dad

  15. 49

    okay I now have a craving for dessert! yummy!
    Jennifer H´s last blog post ..Comment on Walgreens Balance Financial Prepaid MasterCard + #RaceAroundAmerica Sweepstakes by Digna Dreibelbis

  16. 50

    Mmmmm, this looks incredibly refreshing and tasty. I’m always looking for good, new recipes. Thank you for sharing.
    Digna D.´s last blog post ..Purchasing Perfume Online – Finding YOUR Perfect Fragrance

  17. 51

    oh my goodness this looks so good! I can’t wait to try this recipe
    Tammilee´s last blog post ..99 Sweet Pies you are going to love!

  18. 52

    Not a fan of pistachio pudding. But I do love mint! I’ve made an Oreo one before though. Pudding pies are so easy and good!
    Hanan´s last blog post ..12 Heavenly Fruit Pies + A Mini Salted Caramel Apple Pie Recipe

    • 53

      I totally love them because they are so easy. I think pistachio is one of those things that you either love or hate.

  19. 54

    My 5 year old loves pistachios. I just bought him a new bag. I bet he’d like this!

  20. 55

    Oh that looks delicious and my boyfriend loves his pistachios. This might be something I need to make!
    Liz @ A Nut in a Nutshell´s last blog post ..Make Party Clean-up Easier!

  21. 56

    Mmmm. Pudding pies. So many possibilities!

  22. 57

    I never would have thought to put mint with pistachio, but I’m pretty sure that’s one of the most awesome sounding desserts I’ve heard of!!! thanks for posting.

  23. 58

    I can’t handle seeing all these pies. It’s making me so hungry! That one looks so delicious and perfect for St. Patty’s Day!
    Jennifer @ Mom Spotted´s last blog post ..Honey BBQ Slow Cooker Wings #Recipe

  24. 59
    Vickie Couturier says:

    oh my that looks so good,id love to try to make this,,id probably eat it all

  25. 60
    joanna garcia says:

    OMG perfect dessert for St Patricks day and w choc graham cracker crust yummy!!! love mint and this would be awesome!

  26. 61

    YUM! I’m pretty sure this would be my favorite, this looks incredible. I’m a lemon meringue, blueberry and pumpkin pie lover!
    Nichol´s last blog post ..Janie and Jack 2014 Spring Collection has Arrived!

  27. 62

    I love pudding pies! I’m a huge fan of cream pies – coconut cream is my favorite. 🙂
    Donna´s last blog post ..Protecting Your Skin With Sunscreen

  28. 63

    I love that there are pistachios in this! Those are my favorite. Looks delish!
    Lara´s last blog post ..Blogger Tax Tips: 14 Things You Should Know Before Filing

  29. 64

    We’re big fans of Pistachio anything! YUMMMMMMM..
    deb@simpleplate´s last blog post ..5 Tips For A Happy Healthy Self

  30. 65

    This looks like the perfect combo for my hubby and my daughter. Hubby loves pistachio, my daughter loves mint!
    Jamie H´s last blog post ..Leprechaun Doughnuts–Free Printable

  31. 66

    Oh this looks delicious! and i love pistachios too, don’t get to have many desserts with it.

  32. 67
    Mary Happymommy says:

    This would make a perfect dessert for St. Patrick’s Day! I don’t even think it would make it 2 hours in our house. 🙂

96 Flares Twitter 0 Facebook 3 Pin It Share 14 StumbleUpon 79 Filament.io 96 Flares ×